Tag:Brett Favre
Posted on: September 10, 2008 11:46 pm

Carnage's Long and Boring Week 1 Review

    Week 1 of the NFL has been crazy to say the least.  In general, I think we all need to start taking everything we think we know about the NFL at the end of a year and throw it completely away (Aside from the fact that the Lions won’t make the playoffs.  That seems constant).  Teams liked in the preseason: the Indianapolis Colts, Jacksonville Jaguars, San Diego Chargers, and the Seattle Seahawks got knocked off.  Michael Turner ran wild.  Donovan McNabb is wearing a throwback self.  The entire power base of the AFC shifted in one fateful play where Tom Brady injured his leg. 

Tom Brady's Injury -  As I write this, the reports say that Tom Brady is done for the season.  I know some people out there will be cheering about this, saying that “Bellicheat” deserved it.   Have some class.  Anyone getting hurt that badly is bad and any player as good as Tom Brady going down is bad for us all.  The Patriots have been a big part of some absolutely epic AFC Playoff races in the last eight or so years.   Tell me Giants fans?  Was there anything more satisfying than beating the Patriots in the Super Bowl last year?   Colts fans, what game did you enjoy more?  The actual Super Bowl victory against the Rex Grossman led Bears or the masterful comeback against the Tom Brady led Patriots?  Love or hate the Patriots, Brady will be missed in January.

     Run The Ball! – For those of you who have read my material before, you know that I believe that teams should get as close to a 50/50 run/pass split as possible.  Last year, 92% of the time the team that won was the team that ran the ball a higher percentage than threw the ball.   Teams get behind by 7-10 points in the first half and forget their running games.  By becoming one dimensional, they stray from their game plan and end up performing worse.  Let’s see if the trend continued.
     As of the end of the Sunday Night game, 13 of the 14 game winners had a higher percentage of rushing plays called.  The lone exception was the pass wacky Panthers beating the balanced Chargers.  On average, winning teams ran an extremely high 53% of the time while losing teams ran a pathetic 36% of the time.  Before you say “But teams behind by a lot have to throw” I’d like to point out that some of the biggest differences in ratios came in relatively close games.  Titans: 56%, Jags: 29%.  Jets: 55%, Dolphins 26%.  Falcons: 75%, Lions: 36%.  Cardinals: 54%, 49ers 45%.  Ravens: 61%, Bengals 43%. 
      It’s practically clockwork week in and week out.  Coaches get wrapped up sometimes in the brilliant offensive schemes and fail to recognize the obvious fact.  You probably need to run the ball to be successful.  I’m not a purist, I love the passing attack.  I grew up watching Brett Favre.  What I am is a realist, and I’ve been running these numbers long enough to know they do not lie.

Giants over Redskins or “Third down means you need to get to the marker to stay on the field.”

      This offseason I have really wondered if the Redskins with Jason Campbell would have won four tough games to finish the 2007 regular season and get into the playoffs.   I’m really not sure.    Especially on third downs, Jason Campbell did not seem to be going through his progressions and throwing to the check down even when not under pressure.   Four second half drives were stopped after coming up a yard or so short on passing plays.    Another glaring problem?   I think Chris Cooley’s catch was the one time that he was targeted.  Perhaps the Redskins are not yet comfortable with Jim Zorn’s west coast scheme.
       After the Giants beat my Packers in the playoffs last season, I realized that Plaxico Burress is one of those few Wideouts in the NFL that can take over a game.  His sixty yards on the opening drive set the tone for this game.  No disrespect of course to Brandon Jacobs, who somewhat quietly had a huge game on the ground.
       The Giants lost some serious talent on the Defensive side of the ball this season, but don’t count out Justin Tuck.  Some thought his successes were due to having other players to key on, but he’s quick and looks like the real deal.

Statistical Notes – London Fletcher-Baker has 7 seasons of 100+ Tackles.  He was credited with 17 this week.   Plaxico Burress has 18 catches for 277 yards and 3 TD’s in the last two opening day games.    Clinton Portis carried the ball 23 times.  It took until week 8 of last season for him to get more than 20 carries.

Falcons over Lions or “NFL, meet Matt Ryan and Michael Turner.”

      The Falcons offense had a favorable matchup against the Lions questionable Defense, no doubt but I never would have anticipated the dominating performance the Falcons put on.  Having your first Regular Season pass be a 64 yard TD is as sweet as it gets.  The real story however, belongs to Michael Turner and Jerious Norwood who combined for 313 rushing yards, a Falcons franchise record.  That is saying something considering the running treo of Michael Vick, Warrick Dunn, and Norwood two seasons ago.  Even more frightening, they averaged 8.7 yards per carry. 
       For those of you in Fantasy leagues that do NOT have Michael Turner, don’t give away your team to get him.  I expect Turner to have a fine season.  He’s a fast, strong runner with a good first cut and an ability to hit the hole.  Today’s performance however, had a lot to do with the Falcon’s O-Line dominating the Lions defense.  While I think the Falcons have an adequate line I do not think they will push many teams around as they did today.  If You DO have Michael Turner and someone is desperate, now is the time to get value out of him.
       On defense, the Falcons were impressive controlling the line of scrimmage.  Six tackles for a loss and three sacks (All by John Abraham) are a testament to that.  Jon Kitna is going to spend another season getting beat up.  You have to give him a lot of credit.  He’s 35 years old and is going into his third year as a starter behind the Lions special “El Matador” style of blocking.
        The Lions got rid of Mike Martz and claimed they were committed to running the ball more.   21 rushing plays, 36 passing plays.  Not the balance they were thinking.   It’s tempting to forego the run when you have the monster Calvin Johnson and the underrated Roy Williams for wideouts, but it hasn’t worked the last two years.  Guess what?  It probably won’t work again this year. 

Statistical Notes – Actually, Jon Kitna must have felt pretty safe today.  The Three times he was sacked was under his Lions average of 3.6 sacks per game the previous two seasons (He’s been taken down 114 times in 32 games).  Calvin Johnson tied his career high with 7 catches and posted his highest yardage total (2nd 100 yard game of his career).   Roddy White and Jerious Norwood tied for the team high in receptions with…..two.

Titans over Jaguars or “Those who don’t learn from mistakes are doomed to repeat them.”

   Last opening day, the Jaguars handed the ball to Fred Taylor and Maurice Jones-Drew only 13 times against the Titans.  This year, they decided to try that strategy again and gave the duo 14 carries.  Taylor and MJD did not take advantage of those few carries, but that is the strength of this team.  You have to live and die by these guys.  Keep pounding away and trying to get them going, especially in a close game like this.   My opinion of David Garrard has been that he is the type of guy who won’t lose games for you, but I don’t think you can count on him to go out and win them.   The Jags also failed to take advantage of Red Zone chances.  Touchdown, Missed Field Goal, Fumble, Field goal.  10 points inside the Titans’ 20.   You need to get at LEAST 16 points, more like 20 when you get down there.
   Of course, I have to give credit for the Titans front seven being absolutely incredible.  They came up huge, sacking David Garrard seven times and holding the Jags to 1.9 YPC.  The Jags are chic picks for the Super Bowl, but the Titans with that defense looked darn good.
   Speaking of good, Chris Johnson is FAST.  The “Thunder and Lightning” combination of him and LenDale White should keep the chains moving for this team.  My biggest concern for the Titans is Vince Young.  After a pretty decent rookie campaign, I felt he regressed last season and did not play well once again.   This team has been good in spite of, not because of, Young’s performance.   Not to mention Young’s sulking.  Sorry buddy, you are getting paid Millions to perform.  Your team looks like a Contender.  Suck it up and play better.  You aren’t in Texas anymore.   I have to wonder if the Titans aren’t better off looking at replacing him for the season with Kerry Collins if Collins wins 3 or 4 games while Young is out.  You have to convert third downs to win in this league, and you have to pass on third and five+.   Who would you trust to convert third and six?  Collins or Young?

Statistical Notes – David Garrard threw one less interception Sunday than he did ALL of last season.  Vince Young threw more INT’s than TD’s 9 out of 14 games last season.  He’s 1 for 1 already this year.   The Titans had a 100 yard pass catcher in Bo Scaife.  They had two all of last season.  The two teams combined to convert only 8 out of 27 third downs.

Bills over Seahawks or “Mike Holmgren is wondering if he said he’d retire AFTER or DURING this season….”
The Seahawks are In rough shape offensively.  If the Cardinals or 49ers can display any kind of talent they can take this division.  This week they face a Bills defense (That is improved mind you…but still) that was second last in yards allowed, 3rd last in passing yards allowed, and 4th last in yards per carry.   They came out and completed 17/41 passes, were sacked five times, rushed for 80 yards, turned the ball over twice, and averaged 3.8 yards per offensive play.  Just ugly.   Nate Burleson is an explosive player (His touchdown catch is definite highlight material) but it looks like he’s hurt pretty bad now, although I don’t know the official word on it.  If he’s going to miss time, they have nobody to throw to.   Deion Branch is supposed to return soon but I don’t think much of his ability to be a #1 nor his ability to stay on the field.  Hello Seneca Wallace split out! I think the Seahawks are going to go back to handing the ball off more and hope Maurice Morris or Julius Jones can really step up. 
I don’t think the Bills are serious contenders this season, but I love the team.  They have quite a few young, talented, offensive players.   No disrespect to Adrian Peterson, but I think the gap between his talent and Marshawn Lynch’s is smaller than most people believe.  Roscoe Parrish is a big play guy and was both quick and elusive on his punt return.  If Edwards can keep up his good play, Lee Evans may reach his potential.   
I like the Trickery by the Bills.  With only a 10 point lead, they had a fairly easy 36 yard field goal attempt.  With Punter Brian Mooreman as the placeholder, the Bills snuck defensive end Ryan Denney onto the sidelines.   However unlikely this play was, someone on the Seattle Coaching staff should have been watching and screamed “Timeout!”.  Instead, they allowed a punter to throw a touchdown to a defensive end and the game was out of reach.

Statistical Notes – The Bills four highest scoring games last season were 38, 31, 24, and 21.  They put up 34 this weekend.  Lee Evans already has half as many 100 yard games as last season.   When throwing 40+ balls last season, Matt Hasselbeck’s lowest completion number was 26.  He was 17/41 Sunday. 

Ravens over Bengals or “Exhibit A: Why Ocho Cinco wanted out of Cincinatti”

Either reports of the demise of the Ravens D were GREATLY exaggerated or the Bengals are a bigger mess than we could have imagined.  The Bengals couldn’t run, couldn’t pass, and couldn’t keep their offense on the field.   By the Numbers – 8 First downs (2 by Penalty), 2/13 on third down, 154 Total Yards, 2.8 Yards per rush, 10/25 passing with an interception, Time of Possession: 23:45, and their defense outscored their offense 7-3.   Holdouts, Injuries, Arrests…..they’ve taken a toll on this team.  I’m shocked that Marvin Lewis is still employed, but I’m guessing this is his last year as Bengals head coach.
I actually thought Chad Johnson was open on some plays, particularily when Carson Palmer threw one of his interceptions.  Could there be some bad blood between the two that is skewing their on the field relationship?
Michael Vick who?  Meet Joe Flacco.  The Ravens offense isn’t much to write home about and they have to be creative to score some points.  In one of the weirdest plays of the weekend, Joe Flacco rolled out right on a naked bootleg and took the ball himself 38 yards to the house.  I admit to not knowing much about Flacco, but the guy isn’t that fast.  How can you leave THAT much room in front of a quarterback that he has such a clear path to paydirt?
More Trickery – Reverse type plays are often chancy and can yield large losses.  In the first quarter, Mark Clayton took a double reverse at about the 50 yard line and ran, juke, and spun all the way to the end zone.  It wasn’t the prettiest run ever, but it’s another case of the Ravens doing what they must to get into the end zone.
Other than the run, Joe Flacco was….ok in his debut.  He completed just over 50% of his passes, the longest being a fifteen yard completion to Derek Mason.  Ray Rice didn’t look too great, averaging less than 3 yards per carry and fumbling the ball.  Fullback Le’ron Mcclain looked much more effective.  I think this team needs Ray Rice.  As much as I like the trick type plays, the Ravens are going to have to find a way to move the ball.
Statistical Notes – Carson Palmer’s 10 completions for 99 yards are his second worst numbers of his career . The “Worst” was a 5/8 54 yard performance against the Chiefs during the 2005 season when he played only one quarter. T.J. Houshmenzadeh scored a touchdown in the first eight games last season.  He has scored in only 2 of 9 since that time.  Chris Mccallister’s one interception matches last years’ total.
Prognostication or “Carnage Guessing on games”

Obviously I did not blog last week but I wrote down my picks.  I do not gamble on football games because I love Football and I love to gamble.  The two combined would be dangerous.  My wife is gracious enough to put up with the obsessive amount of time I spend on watching games, writing, discussing, and messing with my fantasy lineups.  Losing time is bad enough.  Losing Money….that would not be acceptable.  For that reason, I pick my games without the spread.  It’s easier, I know, but not that easy.  Besides, teams winning and losing is of more importance to the actual NFL than some arbitrary number that a team has to win by.   I’ll post my guesses every week.  Use them to guide your wagers if you place them, post against mine, laugh at me.  Ignore them.  Whatever.  ;)  I’ll post next week’s pick at the end of the column.  This week, I’m 12-4.  I swear I almost wanted to call Bears over Colts for some reason but I didn’t.

Giants over Redskins
Lions over Falcons
Ravens over Bengals
Bills over Seahawks (I insisted that this was going to happen)
Jets over Dolphins
Patriots over Chiefs
Saints over Bucs
Eagles over Rams
Steelers over Texans
Jags over Titans
Cowboys over Browns
Chargers over Panthers
Cardinals over 49ers
Colts over Bears
Packers over Vikings
Broncos Over Raiders

Patriots over Chiefs or “The POP heard around the (Sports) world.”

I already addressed the Brady injury in some form, but now I have to wonder where it leaves the team.  Matt Cassell had a good outing but it WAS the Chiefs.  If Bill Billichick is anything, he is personnel savvy.  I have a feeling that Daunte Culpepper is going to be coaxed out of retirement and be reunited with Randy Moss
The hero of the game for the Patriots was definitely Deltha O’Neal.   You have to like guys that hustle and running down Devard Darling definitely qualifies as hustle.  He kind of made a play keeping Dwayne Bowe out of the end zone in the last play of the game.  As I mentioned about Evil Bill before, he is personnel savvy.  Deltha O’Neal had two subpar seasons in a row for the Bengals and seemed to be nearing the end of his usefulness.  This game proved he still has something left.
The Patriots seem to have a bottomless well of good defensive players.  Lose a solid player here and there, someone steps up.  Mike Vrabel looked fantastic and Jared Mayo seemed to fit into the lineup quite nicely.  Seriously, I don’t really like the Patriots but I have to respect the fact that at all times Patriots defenders all swarm towards the ball.  
Tom Brady wasn’t the only QB to go down.  Brodie Croyle finally was getting a chance to start on opening day and suffered a shoulder injury.  I am not sure it is serious, but it seems to be a continuation of a bad trend in the NFL…Quarterback injuries.
Larry Johnson carried the ball 22 times and managed to gain 74 yards (3.4 YPC), but 22 of those yards were on one play.  That means LJ carried the ball 21 times for 52 yards, a paltry 2.5 Yards per Carry.  I’m not a big fan of Larry Johnson.  He was touted as a Superstar runner in 2005/2006 but he had two all-pro offensive linemen.  I maintain that Larry Johnson is a rather ordinary runner that benefited from a great scenario. 

Statistical Notes:  Tony Gonzales grabbed 6 balls for 55 yards.  Seems a bit pedestrian but that projects to 96 catches for nearly 900 yards.  He’s had at least 70 catches and 900 yards in 7 of the last 8 seasons.   30 year old Randy Moss had another 100 yard game and another touchdown.  He passes Jimmy Smith to move up to 13 on the all time receiving yards list.  He’ll never catch Rice in receptions, but if he plays 5 more years at a high level, he could be knocking on the yardage and touchdowns leader door.

Quarterback Injuries:
  Over the years, the NFL has implemented many measures to keep quarterbacks safe.  Last year was terrible, with NFL QB depth charts looking more like an infirmary.  There is just no getting around the fact that QB’s are often hit when not expecting it or hit with their bodies fully extended, getting rid of the ball.  It truly makes Brett Favre’s (And Peyton Manning’s) consecutive start streak all that more impressive.  
Many people point out Favre’s toughness when talking about his streak.  No doubt he played injured at some points in his career but more than anything, Brett Favre is quite possibly the luckiest man ever to play the position.  Favre’s legendary iron man status wouldn’t allow him to play with a torn ACL or a separated shoulder any more than the next guy.  No Knock on Favre, it’s still quite an accomplishment (Including playing through emotional pain) but don’t think for a second that he has some “Rugged gene” that has kept him from sitting out.

Eagles over Rams or “Donovan Mcnabb addresses his skeptics.”

For a few years now Eagles fans have been thinking of a future without Donovan Mcnabb.   I guess he’s gotten injured a few years, but spast!  He’s one of the best in the league when he’s healthy and playing well.  361 passing yards…and only 1 yard receiving for Brian Westbrook?  100 yard games out of three receivers: a rookie, Hank Baskett, and Greg Lewis?  Are you kidding me?  You can call it a product of Andy Reid’s system….but if that is the case why doesn’t everyone use that system?
Deshaun Jackson has spectacular.  He’s undersized but has some speed.  What impressed me most was the catches he made.  Mcnabb was throwing into pretty decent coverage on at least two of Jackson’s grabs and he hung on to them.  You like to see that in a rookie.  He also looked great on one punt return. 
As bad as the Rams defense was, the offense may have been worse.   Every time I looked, Marc Bulger was being pressured.  Steven Jackson was stuffed for less than 3 yards per carry.  They failed to convert a single third down and had only 8 first downs (Compared to 28 for the Eagles).    There was also a glaring lack of discipline as the team was penalized nine times.  The Greatest Show on Turf is but a distant memory.

Statistical Notes – Tory Holt was held to one catch for the first time since 2004 and only the fourth time in his 142 game career.  The Rams “Contained” Brian Westbrook.  He failed to reach 100 total yards, (He had 93 and 2 touchdowns) a mark he only missed three times last season. 

Steelers over Texans or “Is there a new team to beat in the AFC?”

   Seriously, I have the Texans competing for a wildcard spot.   They went 8-8 in a rough division last year and should only be better this year.  They were completely dominated.   The box score shows that the Texans actually had 230 yards and scored two touchdowns.  Most of those yards and both touchdowns came in the fourth quarter when the game was way over.  Fast Willie Parker looked, well, fast.  Ben Roethisberger was cruelly efficient, completing 13/14 of his pass attempts.  The defense seemed to be on top of Matt Schaub the entire first half. 
   After last year’s poor offensive line play and the loss of Alan Faneca, I thought that the Steelers might have some trouble on offense.  I think I might have been wrong.  While the other powers in the AFC struggled/lost their leaders, the Steelers looked really strong.  After watching how bad the Browns struggled against Dallas, I can’t see them taking the division from the Steelers.
   I think the Texans got hit with a bad opening day matchup.  They ran into a machine.  They have got to protect Matt Schaub better if they are going to do anything.  Granted, one of the INT’s he threw was just an ill advised pass and he held the ball two long on the one of the sacks, but quarterbacks tend to stop thinking clearly when they hear footsteps all day long. 
Statistical notes – The Texans had a few Bright Spots.  Mario Williams started off where he ended last season with two sacks.  He finished last season with 10 in the last seven games.  He’s blossoming into a super pass rusher.  Andre Johnson caught 10 passes for 112 yards and is a top five WR if he stays healthy.   Between Big Ben and Schaub, only 7 of 47 passes hit the ground (Though two were picked off).  Willie Parker had 3 TD’s, one more than all of last season.  Big Ben has thrown more INT’s than TD’s only twice since November 26th of 2006.  Kevin Walter has 4 TD’s in his last 7 games.
Saints over Buccaneers or “The Jeff Garcia Aerial Circus!”
   Last season, I often applauded the Buccaneers for their throwback style of playing.  Work hard on defense, run the ball, throw high percentage passes once in a while.  They performed well enough using this philosophy to get into the playoffs.    Suddenly, in a close game against a division rival they hand the ball to a guy averaging 9.1 YPC only three times in the entire second half of the game.   To their credit they did put up over 350 yards of total offense, which is probably well above last years’ average.
   I loved the swing/screen play to Reggie Bush.  Usually screen plays take some time to develop but Drew Brees hit Reggie Bush on a dead run from the “I” formation.  Bush took that one to the house.  It’s on the highlights.  Neat play.  Both of Reggie’s longer passes came out of the I formation.  You can talk about splitting him out to create mismatches, but I think he may get more running room coming out of the backfield.
    Is it just me or did Drew Brees seem to be throwing the ball harder than in previous years?  He’s been a very good, very accurate passer for awhile now but I felt that the ball was getting to the receivers very quickly and in perfect places.  I think adding Jeremy Shockey is perfect for this offense.   In a standard I set the defense will have to watch out for Marques Colston running all sorts of routes, one of the Saints deep threats, Shockey working the middle and possibly drawing  off linebackers, and Bush swinging or “Sitting Down” in front of the linebackers.  The Bucs were a stout defense last season (2nd in yards allowed, 1st in passing yards allowed, 7th in Yards per Carry, third in takeaways.  The Saints lit them up for 438 yards, a good amount of which were passing yards. 
 Statistical Notes – Reggie Bush’s longest run in 2007 was 22 yards.  He had a 26 yard carry Sunday.  In 2007 his longest reception was 25 yards.  He had catches of 29 and 42 yards Sunday.  Earnest Graham has 6 games of 100+ total yards in his last eight, including doing so on only 12 touches Sunday.  The Saints have not had a Tight End catch 50 passes in a season in a decade.  Shockey had 6 in week 1.  Jeff Garcia has more INT’s (1) than he did in the first 7 games last season. 

    Cowboys over Browns or “I think we should cut the lead to 18.”

    The Browns weren’t going to win this game anyway, but I thought Romeo Crennell’s decision to kick a field goal on 4th and 3 from the 17 yard line, down 21 with 10 minutes to go was utterly ridiculous.  Your team is having only the second substantial drive of the game.  If you pick up the first down and go on to score a touchdown, you are down by only 2 scores with probably over 9 minutes left.  A defensive stand and another score would set you up for a chance at an onside kick or another defensive stand.  Kicking a field goal leaves it at three possessions and tells the players you are calling it a day and sends a message that you do not believe your offense can gain three yards.  There was absolutely nothing good that could come out of kicking a field goal.
     The Cowboys utterly destroyed this team with a potent offense and a supposedly improved defense.   They appeared utterly unstoppable.  The offensive line played tremendously, giving Tony Romo tons of time to throw and blowing open huge holes for Marion Barber and Felix Jones
      For the last two years Marion Barber has been on my list of “Favorite Non-Packers Players” (He and Brian Westbrook are my backfield) and he showed why again this week.  He signed the big contract and he’s still throwing himself around, stiff arming, and generally playing like a wild man.  Truthfully, I think this guy is less talented than a lot of backs in the league, but has so many times more heart and toughness that it doesn’t matter.   My only concern is that he already has some injured ribs.  How many games can you play the way he does and remain healthy?
      I thought the Jason Witten secret was out.  Apparently nobody told the Browns.  I saw him come across the middle, attracting not a single defender to catch a ball, and come off the left side, drifting towards the sidelines to catch a ball…once again not a defender in sight.
     Is it just me or did it look like Derek Anderson (When he had time to throw) seem to have the “Isn’t Braylon Supposed to be there.” Look?  I know Braylon Edwards spent some time injured but I was surprised how out of sync the two looked.  The same problem did not exist with Kellen Winslow.
     This game was rough to watch because of the penalties.  Twenty flags and 130+ yards worth of them.  That breaks down to one every three minutes of game time.  That’s a lot.   I did think the Terrell Owens taunting penalty was a little silly.  There have been far worse stunts than that.

Statistical Notes – Terrell Owens TD was the 130th of his career, putting him tied for second with Cris Carter.  He has at least one score in 9 of his last 11 games.  With 2 TD’s this Sunday, Marion Barber has multiple TD’s in 11 of his 46 career games.  Braylon Edwards caught two or fewer balls only once last season.  He has already matched that low total.  The Cowboys had 30 first downs to the Browns 11.

Jets over Dolphins AND Packers over Vikings or “Brett Favre is the Quarterback for the New York Jets.  He made his first start as a Jet this Sunday.   This means that Brett Favre is not the Green Bay Packers Quarterback.  Aaron Rodgers is the Green Bay quarterback but Aaron Rodgers is NOT Brett Favre.  I figured that you may not have realized this so I thought I would go over it.”
    Seriously, the Brett Favre exposure for the Sunday Pre-Game shows and Monday Night Packers matchup was annoying.   Let me make things clear on where I stand.  I am a Packers fan and I bear no ill will towards Favre or the organization.   I enjoyed watching him play all of these years and still found him fun to watch.  I was excited to see Aaron Rodgers start and fully support him.  In other words, I’m still a Packers fan (Not a “Favre” fan as some people are called) but I do not hate Brett Favre (Which, to some people, makes me not a Packers fan).
   Anyway, having to hear about Favre’s first pass, first completion, first touchdown, first incompletion, first sack taken, first crotch grabbing, and 100 other inane things on Sunday had to have gotten on everyone’s nerves.   We’ve seen Favre throw thousands of passes and score 400+ touchdowns.   I think we were all pretty sure he could throw more passes and score more touchdowns.  I think we all are aware that he is now a Jet.  Twenty Six teams full of players, some of them very talented, played on Sunday.  Maybe shift the news to some others here and there?
Anyway, Favre played pretty well, hooking up with Jericho Cotchery on a textbook Brett Favre fantastic pass and later with Chansi Stuckey on a textbook Favre “Crazy” play.  I’m sure the Jets are happy with Favre’s performance, but I think Thomas Jones’ day was more of a reason to be happy.  The Jets really struggled running the ball last season.  Granted, this was against the Dolphins…..
Jets kicker Mike Nugent hurt himself on a field goal attempt which was a big reason the Dolphins remained in the game to the last minute.  He missed the field goal when he injured himself, and it forced the Jets to go for the deuce with no kicker.  Nugent eventually was able to come back and kick an extra point, but don’t underestimate those little 3 point and 1 point plays.
The Dolphins, reportedly very happy with Ricky Williams and Ronnie Brown, called 47 passes and 17 rushes and ran only 3 times in the second half.  Neither Ricky or Ronnie looked like world beaters but I would have expected more balance with the Tuna hovering over this team.
Statistical Notes – Thomas Jones averaged 4.6 YPC, a full yard over his 2007 average and better than 15 out of 16 games last season.  Anthony Fasano and David Martin are both 1 receiving TD away from tying last years’ Dolphins team leaders in that category.

Favre’s old team game notes

Now, back to Green Bay over Minnesota.  Aaron Rodgers looked really good in his debut, even with the insane amount of penalties committed by the O-Line (The Packers were flagged 12 times for 118 yards).  At one point in the first, the Packers had a 1st and 33 situation.  Tony Kornheiser, who would not shut up about Favre, made it sound like Favre would simply take the snap and immediately complete a 34 yard pass or something.  Is Kornheiser supposed to be an analyst or a comedian?  It’s hard to tell because he’s not very good at either.
Rodgers’ most impressive play in my opinion didn’t make any highlight reels, which is a shame.  In the second quarter, he hit Greg Jennings on a 15 yard or so slant.  I thought it was incredible how quick that ball came out, how fast it got there, and how well it was placed.  Mike Mccarthy obviously wasn’t as impressed.  With 18 seconds on the clock, one timeout, and the Packers on the Vikings 16 yard line…he was content to let the clock run down instead of having Rodgers take a shot at the end zone.  Coach!  Your guy is playing brilliant up to this point!  Go for Seven!  Mason Crosby’s field goal was blocked and they got nothing out of it.
Early in the game, Adrian Peterson looked like he would be extremely difficult to contain with 65 yards rushing in the first quarter.  The Green Bay D really turned it on and help him pretty well past that point.  I think a lot of people are down on Tavaris Jackson, but I thought he played pretty well considering how much pressure the Packers were able to bring.  They only brought him down once as he made some huge plays with his feet but I guarantee he was hurried plenty of times. The abandonment of the high profile running game in the second half didn't help his cause either.  I seriously think he will be a better quarterback by mid season.

Statistical Notes – The Vikings defense gave averaged 3.1 YPC last season.  The Packers gained 5.1 yards per rush Monday Night.   The Vikings averaged more YPC than the Packers, gained more total yards, ran 20 more plays, had the edge in time of possession by 2 minutes, were penalized 74 fewer yards, converted a greater percentage of third downs, and had 21 first downs to the Packers 15.  Stats never tell the entire story.

Panthers over Chargers or “What the? Part 1”
After listening for a week to my friend saying that Dante Rosario was his awesome fantasy sleeper pick and me just laughing.  For that reason, my jaw doubled dropped when Jake Delhomme found Rosario in the end zone as the clock hit triple zero. 
This game was simply shocking to me.  I wasn’t too excited about the Panthers to begin with.  They were without Steve Smith and they were going down to San Diego to play one of the more talented teams in the league.      To be honest, John Kasay was the absolute key to this game.  He nailed four field goals of course, two of them 40+ yarders,  but the more important factor was that following each of those scores he kicked the ball into the end zone giving the Chargers a long field.  8/12 Chargers drives began at their own twenty or worse. 
Although Philip Rivers (Rivers played very well, actually), Antonio GatesLaDainian Tomlinson and the offense played well they never seemed to be able to get into the type of groove we are used to seeing.  Rivers hooked up with Gates, Chris Chambers, and Vincent Jackson on some big plays but they felt a tad out of sync otherwise.  Ladainian Tomlinson was pretty absent from the passing game.  After their slow start last season, I have to wonder if their conservative preseason approach doesn’t leave them a little behind when the season starts.  Due to injuries, it was unavoidable this year but I think even healthy we wouldn’t have seen much of them in pre season.
DeAngelo Williams and Jonathon Stewart both looked sharp.  I like this backfield duo.   Fantasy wise they should be frustrating with each gobbling the other’s carries, but Panther fans should enjoy a fine season of running the ball.

Statistical Notes – Antonio Gates has scored in each of the last three season openers.  Philip Rivers has seven TD’s and 0 INT’s in his last four regular season games.  The Panthers are 3-1 with Jake Delhomme the last two seasons and 5-8 without him.

Bears over Colts or “What the? Part 2”
Heading into the season, there was uncertainty as to Peyton Manning playing the first game.  Many people assumed that the Colts could beat the bears even with Jim Sorgi at the helm.  If Manning plays?  The Bears have no chance at all.
It seems we all forgot that a healthy Bears defense has some serious talent.  With two new players on the Colts O-Line and the obvious absence of Jeff Saturday, the Bears absolutely dominated the line of scrimmage.   Joseph Addai was largely ineffective and the Colts became ridiculously one dimensional, running 15 times out of 66 total plays.  The Bears D put up Nine points themselves and the safety set up a short field and eventual field goal.  I’ve always respected the Bears and their ball slapping ways and once again it paid off with Charles Tillman popping the ball from Marvin Harrison’s usually sure hands.  They put pressure on Peyton Manning, making him settle for shorter throws and did a nice job tackling the Colts talented receiving crew. 
What is especially surprising is the fact that the Bears actually outgained the Colts and were far more efficient on third down.   Pounding away all night with rookie Matt Forte and Kevin Jones opened the way for Kyle Orton to make just enough plays to win. 
I think within two weeks Peyton Manning and his crew will get in sync with each other (Although I don’t know the status of Dallas Clark….if he is going to miss time that would be huge.) 

Statistical Notes – Matt Forte’s 123 yard performance tops Cedric Benson’s lone 100 yard game (101 yards) from last season.    Reggie Wayne has 32 catches in his last three regular season outings.

Next Week’s Predictions.
Chicago over Carolina – Matt Forte has another big day and the Panthers struggle against the tenacious Bears defense. 
Jaguars over Bills – Jacksonville looked bad last opening day.  They are a solid team.  The Bills keep it surprisingly close.  I like Marshawn Lynch and Maurice Jones-Drew in this one. 
Chiefs over Raiders – The Raiders looked terrible Monday Night.   Darren McFadden has a better outing though.  Tony Gonzales will catch a lot of balls.
Vikings over Colts – If Matt Forte was so effective against the Colts, Adrian Peterson should be at least that much.  The Colts offensive line did not look good and the Colts are going to be throwing a lot.  Jared Allen will bring the heat in this one.
Saints over Redskins – The Saints were able to move the ball against the Bucs and should be able to do so against the Redskins.  I expect good numbers out of Drew Brees again. Clinton Portis should have a big game if they feed him the ball.  I am just not sold on Jason Campbell at this point.
Giants over Rams – The Rams SHOULD be better on Turf but they looked too horrible to consider picking.  Jacobs, Manning, and Burress could all put up some numbers.
Packers over Lions – The Lions D is porous and the Packers could have a field day in the Lions backfield.
Titans over Bengals – I’m picking too many road games but the Bengals did not look good in any way.  I seriously may even sit Palmer, Housh, and CJ if I had better options.
49ers over Seahawks – The Seahawks are in disarray.  The 49ers are going to have a hard time scoring but Matt Hasselbeck throwing to Seneca Wallace doesn’t appeal to me.
Buccaneers over Falcons – Michael Turner and Matt Ryan come back to Earth.
Arizona over Miami – Arizona may suddenly be the team to beat in the west.  Miami is better…..just not much better.
Jets over Patriots – Matt Cassel starting his first game.  Jets at home and looking pretty good.
Broncos over Chargers – Jay Cutler was scary good without Brandon Marshall.  He gets him back this week.  Tomlinson runs wild but the Broncos take it at Mile High.  Chargers start 0-2 for the second year running.
Texans over Ravens – The Ravens won but struggled to move the ball on the Bengals.  Flacco will actually be facing a pass rush.
Steelers over Browns – I called Steelers over Browns x2 before the season started and week 1 makes me feel stronger about that pick.
Cowboys over Eagles – Great Monday night matchup.  We get to see if the Eagles are for real or if the Rams are THAT bad.  The Cowboys looked too good to pass up at home.

Whew.  Long review to start the season.  I’ll try to make it shorter and more exciting next time.
Posted on: August 1, 2008 7:40 pm

20 Million Reasons for Brett to go away

     I really don't know what seems more ridiculous to me, the fact that the Packers are trying to pay Brett Favre $20,000,000 to stay at home or the fact that Brett Favre is thinking about it.  

    Maybe I've been the one that has had the wool pulled over my eyes but when I heard the announcement that Favre had been offered a pile of money to NOT play football, I thought no way would he accept that.

   You see, I've defended Favre in a way.  He was my childhood hero and even as a more pragmatic adult watching him play football has been enough to make me smile.   Some of his antics have allowed me to keep a shred of childish naivite in my older, suspicious, world weary mind.  I've said "Hey, the guy just wants to play football.  Can't fault him for that."  through all of this.   Now I see a guy that just wants to make football....or maybe just wants to make loads of cash.  I know that $20 Million is a lot of money.  I know it wouldn't take half that for me to never show up at work again.  I know everyone has their price....

    But Brett Favre is supposed to be the type of guy above that.  He is supposed to be the guy that would do anything to get on a football field anywhere. Brett Favre is the guy who even at age 37 played with "Youthful Exuberance" or whatever the media always called it.  Brett Favre isn't the guy who takes a payoff (To add to his already certainly large pile of money) to NOT play the game. 

   Brett, if the possibilty of polarizing your old teammates and creating quite a stir didn't make you want to stay at home, if the prospect of playing for *Gasp* THE ENEMY Minnesota Vikings didn't make you want to stay home, this horribly convuluted $20 Million offer better not make you want to stay home. 
   I could accept almost any resolution to the Brett Favre Crisis.  I could accept him deciding again that he doesn't have the will to play, I could accept him forcing himself back into his old position, I could accept him holding a clipboard. I could accept him as a Jet, and I could even accept him on the Bears or Vikings.   This "Payout" is something I cannot accept.  It's a cowardly gesture by the Packers front office and it would be a cowardly offer to accept.

   If this monetary offer does do the trick, everyone on the Packers franchise will breathe a sigh of relief.  Green Bay will be able to "Move On" officially.  Maybe they'll even retire Brett's number on that opening Monday Night Game........and I'll boo Brett Favre every appearance that he makes be it his number retirement, his Hall of Fame induction ceremony, any broadcasts he ends up doing...anything.  I will boo loud, long, and hard.  You made me actually believe that you were driven by things that are beyond that of ordinary men.  You made me believe your motives were as innocent as just wanting to play a game.  You made me believe that the money wasn't part of this.  You made me believe that you had some pure motives the likes that I have not even dreamed existed since I was a kid.

Posted on: July 14, 2008 11:51 pm

Brett Favre wrong, but what about the Packers?

Let me just say that I am absolutely a Packers fan first, but Brett Favre has always been my favorite player.  I'm really not angry about this situation at all.  Whatever happens, happens.

Brett Favre has been taking a lot of flak lately.  I see his name being dragged all over the mud on these forums and elsewhere....but let's consider something for a second.  Let go of your thoughts of Favre being a drama queen and what not and let's talk about the thing that is actually important...winning football games.

I have to wonder...what are the Packers doing?  They have a few options here....invite Favre back onto the team, try and trade Favre, or release Favre.

Right now, with Favre retired, the only thing going on for them is taking somewhere around $2 Million in dead money as a cap hit.  Brett Favre sitting at home retiring is not actually helping the Packers whatsoever.   The thing is, Favre apparently does not want to stay at home.  He wants to play football....if not in Green Bay then somewhere.

Brett Favre being reinstated as a backup is not a legitimate possibility.  The cap hit would increase to about $12 Million.  You don't pay someone $12 Mil to carry a clipboard.....and to be honest Favre just has to say the word "I'm Back" and the Packers HAVE to make the decision.

Now is where things get interesting.  Let's look at the state of the Packers team right now.  They are a contender.  No doubt.  They have a lot of talented players.  You will hear about how young of a team they are and assume they are all set to go with a young QB to be great for awhile. 

The reality of the situation is that while they are a young team....five HUGE members of the team.....Al Harris, Charles Woodson, Donald Driver, Chad Clifton, and Mark Tauscher will have an average age over 32 when the season starts.   Al Harris hits 34 by playoff time.  Two years from now, these players are not going to be at the high level they are now.   Oh yeah, and with the exceptions of Aaron Kampmann, Nick Barnett, and POSSIBLY Ryan Grant they are the five best players on the roster.

This means the Window of opportunity is not that wide as the "Average Age" suggests that it is.   By Window of Opportunity I mean going to another Super Bowl.  After all, the franchise doesn't owe the fans Brett Favre, they don't owe them Aaron Rodgers, they don't owe them some vague statement about moving forward...they owe them making the most of a roster filled with solid players.

So who gives you the chance to win when they have to...which would be now?  Aaron Rodgers or Brett Favre?

Let's say you choose Aaron Rodgers as your answer.  That means you really don't have much faith in Brett Favre's ability to take a team to the next level.  Why then, are they unwilling to let Brett Favre go?  Why then aren't they looking to shop Favre around and steal a first or second round pick in exchange for an ancient QB that can't take a team to the big dance?   I hope it's not because they are "Trying to protect Favre's Legacy in Green Bay" because if Favre is not going to be a Packer....that isn't what they owe the fans.  In reality it is because they have no guts.  They don't want to say they believe so much in Aaron Rodgers and take the chance of him failing next season while Favre runs rampant for a different city.

So, Packers front office, I implore you to do SOMETHING.  If you don't feel Favre can take this team all the way, part ways with him.  Free up some cap room.  Grab a Veteran backup player for another position that is still on the market.  Get some Value for him in a trade.  Do something to give the fans what you owe them....some way to make the team better out of this.  Do it soon so this distraction doesn't drag out into August which would also hurt the team.    Don't play games because Brett Favre upset you by playing the retire/do not retire card, games such as these by management should be beneath professionals.   If you think Favre is acting like a child, act like men, stand by your decision, and make a move.  The public turned on Favre but the crowds are fickle.  Tread Carefully Ted Thompson, Mark Murphy, and Mike Mccarthy....lest the crowds turn on you.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or CBSSports.com